Karbon vs TaxDome: shared email or one client hub, per user or per client
Karbon is built around shared email and charges per user ($59 or $89 a user a month, billed annually); TaxDome combines email, texting and chat in one inbox and charges per active client ($1,500 a year covers 150). Karbon includes capacity planning on every plan and connects to Xero; TaxDome includes IRS transcripts, two-way texting and tax-software links. Clients can answer requests and send files in PocketFirm.
The differences that matter
| Karbon | TaxDome | Firmary | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you pay | Per user: Team $59, Business $89 a month, billed annually ($79 / $99 monthly) | Per active client: $1,500 a year for 150 and 20 seats | Starting at $125 a month for one person; request a quote for 20 or more people |
| Small-team terms | Monthly billing needs 4+ users; no part-time rate | $1,500 minimum below 150 clients | Solo from one person; Practice from five |
| Plan limits | Team: 40 work templates, 3 teams, 1,000 contacts | One plan; Custom above 20 seats or 3,000 clients | |
| How the team works | Shared, assigned and commented email from connected inboxes | Email, SMS and chat in one inbox | Messages and texts on the client record; Gmail or Outlook connected |
| Automation | Task automation and automatic client reminders need Business | Included in the one plan | Form answer → task; stage change → request |
| Capacity planning | Every plan | Included | No |
| Texting | Not listed | Two-way SMS | Through your phone system |
| Tax software | ProConnect (return statuses) | Reads prior-year returns from 6 programs | None |
| Xero | Yes, and Xero Practice Manager | Not listed | No |
| KBA | 2 eSignature credits per KBA request | Included | No |
| Card / ACH fees | 2.6% + $0.30 (standard card) / 1% + $0.30, max $5 | 2.9% + $0.30 / 1%, max $10 | Your own Stripe account; payment-processing fees vary |
| Your own AI | Public MCP server announced 3 Jun 2026, availability not stated; Karbon AI on every plan; Kai open to a limited group of firms | Firm MCP and API with the $200-a-month AI add-on | Comes with Firmary |
| Trial | No self-serve trial; guided demo | Demo; no trial listed | By invitation |
| Security statement | SOC 2 Type 2; SOC 3 report available | SOC 2 Type II | No SOC 2 yet; one planned |
Choose Karbon if
- Your team already runs on email and wants to share, assign and comment on it.
- You need capacity planning now, on the entry plan.
- Your clients are on Xero, or you use Xero Practice Manager.
- You file in ProConnect and want return statuses pulled in.
Choose TaxDome if
- You want texting, transcripts and KBA included without extra plans.
- You’d rather pay per client than per person.
- You want the checklist built from last year’s return in Drake, UltraTax, Lacerte or another of its six programs.
Where Firmary fits
Firmary is for a firm that wants client work to run through a client app (PocketFirm, signed in with a link and a code) rather than through shared email; whose staff want to use Claude, ChatGPT or Codex on the firm’s records without an AI add-on; and that texts clients from its own phone system. It isn’t a fit if you need capacity planning, Xero, tax-software links or KBA.
Sources
Karbon pricing · TaxDome pricing. Karbon’s MCP announcement: CPA Practice Advisor, 3 Jun 2026. Other facts from Karbon’s integrations, client portal and security pages and TaxDome’s AI, payments and security pages, read 12 November 2026.
Questions
Is Karbon or TaxDome cheaper for a small team?
Five Karbon Team users cost $3,540 a year, billed annually. TaxDome’s minimum is $1,500 a year, which covers up to 150 active clients.
Does Karbon have texting?
Two-way SMS isn’t listed on Karbon’s pricing or client portal pages. TaxDome lists it.
Which one has an MCP server?
TaxDome released one on 28 Oct 2026, with its AI add-on. Karbon announced one on 3 Jun 2026 without saying when it would be available.