Firmary vs Karbon
Karbon prices per user: Team is $59 and Business $89 per user a month billed annually ($79 and $99 monthly), and monthly billing needs four or more users. Karbon is built around shared email, and its task automation and automatic client reminders need Business. Firmary starts at $125 a month for one person, and firms of 20 or more people can request a quote.
What Karbon costs
| Karbon, as of 12 November 2026 | |
|---|---|
| Team | $59 a user a month billed annually; $79 billed monthly |
| Business | $89 a user a month billed annually; $99 billed monthly |
| Enterprise | Custom |
| Monthly billing | Only for teams of four or more users |
| Part-time staff | No reduced rate; archived users’ unused time is credited |
| Team plan limits | 40 work templates, 3 teams, 1,000 contacts |
| Business plan limits | 75 templates, 10 teams, unlimited contacts |
| E-signatures | Sold as credit bundles; a KBA request uses two credits |
| Card / ACH payments | 2.6% + $0.30 standard card, 3.6% + $0.30 premium card, 3.9% + $0.30 Amex; ACH 1% + $0.30, max $5 |
| Trial | No self-serve trial; guided demos with a sample of your own data |
| 5 users for a year | Team $3,540; Business $5,340 (billed annually) |
Source: Karbon pricing.
Side by side
| Karbon | Firmary | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Per user, from $59 a month billed annually | Starting at $125 a month for one person; request a quote for 20 or more people |
| Your own AI | Public MCP server announced 3 Jun 2026, availability not stated; Karbon AI on every plan; Kai open to a limited group of firms | Claude, ChatGPT and Codex; MCP server; comes with Firmary |
| Client app | Magic link by email, no account needed; web and app with your logo (Karbon-branded in the stores) | PocketFirm in the browser, link and one-time code, at your own domain |
| Automation | Task automation and automatic client reminders on Business | Form answer → task; stage change → request |
| Capacity planning | Every plan | No |
| Texting | Two-way SMS not listed | Through your phone system |
| CRM / pipeline | Client management; no pipeline listed (integrates with HubSpot and Pipedrive) | Prospects pipeline |
| Ledger | QuickBooks Online Accountant; Xero and Xero Practice Manager | QuickBooks Online |
| Tax software | ProConnect | None |
| Billing | Recurring billing, auto-payments and surcharges | Invoices and Stripe payments; recurring fees charged to the client’s saved card or bank account; clients can also turn on autopay for invoices |
| Security statement | SOC 2 Type 2; SOC 3 report available | No SOC 2 yet; one planned |
When Karbon is the better choice
- Your team lives in shared email.
- You need capacity planning on the entry plan.
- Your clients are on Xero, or you use Xero Practice Manager.
- You file in ProConnect and want return statuses in your practice tool.
- You want Karbon’s built-in AI at no extra cost.
When Firmary is the better choice
- Your staff want to use their own Claude, ChatGPT or Codex on client records now. Karbon announced an MCP server on 3 June 2026 but hasn’t said when it will be available.
- You text clients through your own phone system; Karbon doesn’t list two-way texting.
- You want a pipeline for new business built in.
Moving from Karbon
Karbon lists data export as “Standard” on Team and Business. Firmary Switch also reads Karbon in your own browser, signed in as you, and only reads. Move to Firmary stages the supported records as a dry run to check first. A Firmary specialist can do the move with you. How moving in works
- Clients and contactsStaged
- Jobs and recurring workStaged
- TasksStaged
- Invoices and paymentsStaged
- TimeStaged
- Document archiveStaged
How we checked
Karbon’s pricing, integrations, client portal, AI, Kai, services and security pages, read 12 November 2026, and CPA Practice Advisor’s report of 3 June 2026 for the MCP announcement.
Firmary in specifics
| Price | Solo is $125 a month for one person, plus $85 for each person you add. Practice is $400 a month for 5 people, plus $80 for each person you add. Both plans have every feature. Firms of 20 or more can request a quote. |
|---|---|
| AI apps staff can work from | Claude (web, desktop, mobile and Claude Code), ChatGPT and Codex, within each person’s permissions. Each agent’s rule: On its own, Asks first or Never. Every agent action is logged. |
| Client app | PocketFirm, under the firm’s brand at pocketfirm.app or the firm’s own domain. Opens in any phone or computer browser with nothing to install; clients sign in from a link and a one-time code. |
| Texting | Through the firm’s own phone system: Allo, Quo (OpenPhone), Dialpad, RingCentral or Zoom Phone. |
| Moving in | From TaxDome, another practice tool or spreadsheets, with Firmary Switch (Chrome) and Move to Firmary, staged as a dry run first. |
| Firmary Switch | Only reads: it never types, saves, sends or deletes in the old tool. |
Last checked: 11 November 2026.
Questions
What are the alternatives to Karbon?
Our comparison covers TaxDome, Canopy, Financial Cents, Uku, Firm360, Jetpack Workflow, Firmary and others.
Does Karbon have a free trial?
No self-serve trial, as of 12 November 2026. Karbon offers guided demos with a sample of your firm’s data.
Can Karbon bill monthly for a small team?
Monthly billing needs four or more users. Smaller teams pay annually.
Does Karbon work with ChatGPT or Claude?
Karbon announced a public MCP server on 3 June 2026; the announcement didn’t say when it would be available.
Can we move from Karbon?
Yes. Firmary Switch reads Karbon, and Move to Firmary stages it as a dry run.
Hello, Sam
Your next steps3All requests
Your contact
- Megan CarterBrightwater Tax