Karbon vs Canopy: two per-user tools, compared on what you’d actually pay for
Karbon and Canopy both charge per user. Karbon costs less per seat ($59 against $74 a month, billed annually) and includes capacity planning on every plan; Canopy includes a CRM and automated task workflows on its entry plan and sells tax resolution as an add-on. Both connect to Xero and include KBA at a per-use cost. Clients can open PocketFirm in their browser. They can sign in with an email link if their firm allows it.
What five users cost, before add-ons
| Plan | Arithmetic | A year |
|---|---|---|
| Karbon Team | 5 × $59 × 12 | $3,540 |
| Karbon Business | 5 × $89 × 12 | $5,340 |
| Canopy Standard | 5 × $74 × 12 | $4,440 |
| Canopy Plus | 5 × $109 × 12 | $6,540 |
| Firmary Practice | $400 a month for 5 people × 12 | $4,800 |
What moves the number: Karbon’s task automation and automatic client reminders need Business. Canopy’s capacity planning needs Plus. Canopy’s add-ons (Tax Workflow Automation from $34 a client credit after 5 included, Close Automation $10 a connected client a month after 5 included, Tax Resolution $50 a user a month) are on top.
The differences that matter
| Karbon | Canopy | Firmary | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How the team works | Shared, assigned email from connected inboxes | Gmail and Outlook in a unified inbox | Messages and texts on the client record |
| Automation | Task automation needs Business | Automated and recurring task workflows on Standard | Form answer → task; stage change → request |
| Capacity planning | Every plan | Plus | No |
| CRM | No pipeline listed; integrates with HubSpot and Pipedrive | CRM on every plan | Prospects pipeline |
| Proposals | Engagements with upfront payment collection | Proposals that can create tasks and invoices once signed | Templates per service; reminders days 3, 6, 9 |
| Client sign-in | Magic link by email, no account needed; web and app (Karbon-branded in stores) | Mobile app; single-use secure links | Link and one-time code |
| Tax software | ProConnect | Saves files from UltraTax, Drake, Lacerte, ProSeries, CCH Axcess Tax, TaxWise | None |
| KBA | 2 credits per request | $1.25 a credit | No |
| Card fees | 2.6% + $0.30 (standard card) | 3.30% + $0.20 | Your own Stripe account; payment-processing fees vary |
| Your own AI | MCP server announced 3 Jun 2026; Karbon AI included | Not listed; Coworker in open beta | Claude, ChatGPT, Codex; comes with Firmary |
| Trial | No self-serve trial | Through a sales demo | By invitation |
| Security statement | SOC 2 Type 2 | SOC 2 Type II | No SOC 2 yet; one planned |
Choose Karbon if
- Your team works from shared email.
- You want capacity planning without moving to a higher plan.
- You want the lower per-seat price and can live without a sales pipeline.
Choose Canopy if
- You want automated task workflows on the entry plan.
- You want a CRM built in.
- You do tax resolution, or save files out of UltraTax, Drake, Lacerte, ProSeries, CCH Axcess Tax or TaxWise.
Where Firmary fits
Firmary is for a firm whose staff want to use Claude, ChatGPT or Codex on the firm’s records under rules the owner sets, whose clients won’t install an app or create a password, and that texts clients through its own phone system. It isn’t a fit if you need capacity planning, Xero, tax-software links or KBA.
Sources
Karbon pricing · Canopy pricing. Other facts from each vendor’s integrations, client portal, workflow and security pages, read 12 November 2026; Karbon’s MCP announcement in CPA Practice Advisor, 3 Jun 2026.
Questions
Is Karbon cheaper than Canopy?
Per seat, yes: $59 against $74 a user a month on the entry plans, billed annually. Add the features you need (automation on Karbon, capacity planning on Canopy) before comparing.
Do both work with Xero?
Yes, by their own integrations pages.
Which has a client app my clients won’t need a password for?
Canopy’s single-use secure links skip sign-in for one task. Karbon’s client portal sends a magic link by email, so clients can complete requests and sign without an account or password. PocketFirm uses a link and a one-time code.